R8 vs 911 Carrera S vs AM V8 Vantage

Discussion in 'Car Comparisons' started by jason vk, Feb 25, 2007.

  1. Audi R8 (420hp), Porsche 911 Carrera S (355hp), Aston Martin V8 Vantage (380hp)

    These 3 cars are targeted at the same price range. What would be your choice? The power and futuristic looks of the R8? The engineering excelence and perfect, involving as no other handling of the Porsche? Or the astonishing beauty, the distinctive badge and the unique sense of ocasion and bespoke feel of the Aston Martin?
     
  2. Can I have a GranTurismo?
     
  3. 1 Aston
    2 Porsche








    3 Audi
     
  4. r8
    911
    v8vantage
     
  5. 1.)Vantage
    2.)R8
     
  6.  
  7. The Audi, surprisingly.
     
  8. a few weeks ago it wouldve been the R8, now I love the V8 Vantage

    but I'd still want to drive the 911
     
  9. R8 Probaly
     
  10. V8 Vantage>911>>>>>>>R8
     
  11. Hard, both the Porsche and Aston give me wood. I'll give the nod to Porsche, just. Audi... meh.
     
  12. This is very difficult. I'll go with the Audi, barely.
     
  13. R8, Aston, Porsche.
     
  14. Hard choice between the 911 and the V8 Vantage but went with the Aston because of it's looks.
     
  15. I can't believe the R8 is winning
     
  16. v8 vanatge
    911

    the r8 is somewhat off the pace imo
     
  17. R8
    911/Vantage
     
  18. the one with the engine way out back.
     
  19. R8... more exclusivity
     
  20. I couldn't agree more.
     
  21. Aston Martin
    Audi
    Porsche
     
  22.  

Share This Page