Special Feature

The “Greatest” Debate

Michael Lawrence

You know the eternal pub debate about who is the greatest driver ever, or which was the greatest drive? I’m up for that, provided it is a debate, in a pub, with friends. In the right atmosphere it’s great fun, but it’s best left in the pub. To really know the answer we’d need all the candidates in their prime in perfectly matched Maserati 250Fs, Ferrari F2004s etc. and run them on the Nordschleife, Monza, Spa and so on. Unless that could be arranged there can be no resolution and, besides, who would chose the candidates?

We live in an age obsessed by lists and I am getting bothered by the tendency for some automotive magazines to compile lists of the greatest this or that. They judge rather than celebrate. Rarely, if ever, do they stimulate debate and, worst of all, they lead writers to assume that certain opinions are universally held and are therefore virtually fact.

Main Topic Hubs

Join The Community

Become A Member

 

Members only$35 / year

Keep going. This is where it gets good.

Stuttcars Membership is for people who'd rather spend an hour inside one option code than skim ten headlines. The rest of this story — and every other one like it — is a few seconds away.

  • Every members-only story

    Deep history, driven reviews, market reports and the full archive.

  • No ads. None.

    The whole site reads like a magazine, on every device.

  • Every Porsche, researched

    Model-by-model hubs: production numbers, specs, options, colors.

  • 30% off the shop

    Every Stuttcars shirt and piece of merch, all year.

Join Stuttcars — Keep Reading

$35 a year. Cancel anytime, no hoops.
Already a member? Sign in

BY PORSCHE PEOPLE, NOT A CORPORATION. Your membership keeps a small independent team of historians, ex-racers, engineers and journalists doing this.

Join — Keep Reading $35/yr