458 Italia Vs SLS AMG

Discussion in 'Car Comparisons' started by mafalda, Apr 23, 2010.

  1. #1 mafalda, Apr 23, 2010
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 25, 2016
    Quattroruote 05/2010
    458 Italia Vs SLS AMG

    Top Speed
    458: 327.8 Kph
    SLS: 314.9 Kph

    ACC Kph:
    458:
    0-100 3.27s
    0-160 6.5s
    0-200 9.69s <A BORDER="0" HREF="http://www.supercars.net/PitLane?displayFAQ=y"><IMG BORDER="0" SRC="pitlane/emoticons/amazed.gif"></A>
    0-250 16.0s
    1/4 mile 11.0s @ 212.8 Kph <A BORDER="0" HREF="http://www.supercars.net/PitLane?displayFAQ=y"><IMG BORDER="0" SRC="pitlane/emoticons/amazed.gif"></A>
    1 Km 19.8s @ 269.8 Kph <A BORDER="0" HREF="http://www.supercars.net/PitLane?displayFAQ=y"><IMG BORDER="0" SRC="pitlane/emoticons/amazed.gif"></A>

    SLS:
    0-100 3.96s
    0-160 7.7s
    0-200 11.5s
    0-250 19.3s
    1/4 mile 11.8s @ 202.2 Kph
    1 Km 21.0s @ 257.5 Kph

    BRAKES (cold):
    458:
    100-0 36.9m
    200-0 134.8m (-1.17g)

    SLS:
    100-0 39.8m
    200-0 143.0m (-1.10g)

    Vairano handling
    458: 1.15:146 (new record) Michelin Pilot Sport 3
    SLS: 1.17:065 (impressive)

    http://www.supercars.net/PitLane?viewThread=y&gID=3&fID=0&tID=71292

    skipad
    458: 1.20g
    SLS: 1.13g

    Weight
    458: 1,533 Kg
    SlS: 1,701 Kg

    Wha's good / no good
    458 (90/100)
    +
    ALL!!
    prerformances
    living and driving
    -
    small digital speedo

    SLS (89/100)
    Performance
    cockpit and gadgets
    amazing driving
    -
    hard setup (surprise...)
    warranty (just 2 years)
    DTC slowen in manual mode
     
  2. Thanks ! What's the score of the SLS (you write 90/100 for the 458)?
     
  3. I'd be more than happy with either car
    When not racing, which is the most comfortable for every day (traffic) use?
     
  4. 89/100 (fixed)
     
  5. Thanks!
     
  6. both supercars are very use-friendly for a everyday use
    but 458 has a better DTC (manual and automatic too) and, suprise a better comfort from suspension. Quattroruote writes about SLS "sometimes your spine doesn't the asphalt's imperfections"
     
  7. For looks I'm afraid I'd pick the SLS
    458 is awesome as well... whatever I pick, I'll probably regret it
     
  8. Both are great and examples of everything that's right with supercars today. The 458 is just too good not to choose though.
     
  9. 458 with manual please.
     
  10. damn ive been waiting for this for a long time.
     
  11. SLS in a heartbeat. keep that misshapen red thing away from me.
     
  12. Id pick the 458 because its the better looking and better sounding and faster car. but unless ferrari has underrated the power of the 458 by A LOT, then ill believe it trapping 133 mph when other independant tests and owners confirm it.
     
  13. I'm a huge fan of grand tourers so im going to have to go with the SLS on this one, if I wanted something along the lines a 458 i'd probably choose a Gallardo instead though

    edit: sls in this color please
     
  14. I still like the Ferrari better
     
  15. Is that really hard to believe with the combination of it's power to weight ratio, modern tires, launch control, and a 7 speed dual clutch?
     
  16. Both are great cars. I like the 458 more.
     
  17. its power to weight ratio is nothing that we havent seen before. at 3400 lbs and 562 hp (assuming its not underrated), its power to weight ratio is FAR inferior to an Enzo or ZR1. those two cars can trap 130+ mph mainly because of their power.

    the numbers we have here say the 458 is quicker than an Enzo from 0-250+ sorry, but the Enzo may have the inferior gearbox, but its got an extra 100 hp and weighs even less.

    edit: forums being weird, ill post the rest of my reply later.
     
  18. when the 599 came out the magazines were getting some insane times out of it. 0-160
     
  19. SLS please.
     
  20. Both. If you're gonna dream, dream big.
     
  21. the mercedes rear is weird give me the ferrari
     
  22. #22 burner, Apr 24, 2010
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 25, 2016
  23. 3700 lb sports cars are for old men. I'm old but I'm not THAT old. 458 please.

    Edit: I'm not a chick either.
     
  24. You are pretty old.
     
  25. both of them will smoke your mrdeuce. And the SLS is much less a mid life crisis car.
     

Share This Page